Michigan DUI Playbook | Attorney Jonathan Paul
  • DUI Playbook
  • Survival Guides
    • Oakland County >
      • Novi
      • Troy Clawson
      • Farmington Hills
      • Bloomfield Hills
      • Rochester Hills Auburn Hills
      • Royal Oak/Berkley
      • Southfield
      • Clarkston
      • Oak Park
      • Waterford
    • Wayne County >
      • Plymouth Canton Northville
      • Livonia
      • Westland
      • Dearborn
      • Woodhaven Brownstown Twp Trenton
      • Romulus Van Burn Twp Belleville
      • Wyandotte Riverview
      • Dearborn Heights
      • Taylor
    • Macomb County >
      • Clinton Township
      • Shelby Township
      • Warren
      • St. Clair Shores
      • Sterling Heights
      • Fraser Roseville
      • Chesterfield New Baltimore
      • Romeo
    • Washtenaw County >
      • Ann Arbor
      • Saline
      • Chelsea
      • Pittsfield Twp
      • Ypsilanti
      • Ypsilanti Twp
    • Lenawee County
    • Genesee County
    • Monroe County
    • Jackson County
    • Livingston County
  • Offenses
    • Operating While Impaired
    • Super Drunk | High BAC
    • Operating Presence Drugs
    • Operating While Intoxicated
    • Minor BAC | Zero Tolerance
    • DUI Expungement
    • OWI Child Endangerment
    • Felony DUI Third Offense
    • DUI Videos
  • Growth Mindset
  • Common Issues
    • Making Substantial Changes
    • Experience Change Model
    • Trial Videos
    • Can the prosecutor prove I was driving?
    • What are my bond conditions?
    • Out of State License
    • Surviving the Implied Consent Law
    • CDL Concerns
    • Field Sobriety / PBT
    • How to beat the blood draw
    • How to beat the Datamaster
  • 5-Star Defense
  • Contact Me
    • Our Team
    • Client Application
  • DUI Expungement
  • Prosecutor Confessions
    • Why I became a Defense Lawyer
    • OWI First Offense
    • OWI Second Offense
    • OWI Third Offense
    • Field Sobriety Tests
    • Implied Consent
    • Hardship Appeal
    • Chemical Tests
    • Sobriety Court
  • Courts
    • Oakland County >
      • More Courts >
        • Oak Park
        • Madison Heights
        • Hazel Park
        • Ferndale
        • Pontiac
        • Waterford
      • Novi 52-1
      • Clarkston 52-2
      • Rochester Hills 52-3
      • Troy 52-4
      • Royal Oak 44th
      • Southfield 46th
      • Farmington Hills
      • Bloomfield 48th
    • Washtenaw County >
      • Ann Arbor
      • Pittsfield Twp 14A1
      • Ypsilanti 14-A
      • Ypsilanti 14-B
      • Chelsea 14A3
      • Saline 14A4
    • Wayne County >
      • More Courts >
        • Redford
        • Lincoln Park
        • 25th District Court Ecorse
        • Wyandotte
        • Southgate
        • 30th District Court Highland
        • Hamtramck
        • Dearborn Heights
        • 32nd District Court Harper Woods
      • Livonia
      • Plymouth 35th
      • Allen Park
      • Romulus
      • Grosse Pointe
      • Woodhaven
      • Dearborn
      • Detroit
      • Garden City
      • Westland
    • Macomb County >
      • Center Line District Court
      • Clinton Township
      • Eastpointe District Court
      • Fraser | Roseville
      • Shelby Township
      • Sterling Heights
      • St Clair Shores
      • New Baltimore | Chesterfield
      • Warren
    • Livingston County
    • Genesee County
    • Jackson County
    • Monroe County
    • Lenawee County
  • Leading with Empathy
  • Reviews
dui attorney michigan arrest

Charged with Drunk Driving in Lenawee County - Adrian - Blissfield - Tecumseh - Clinton - Field Sobriety Tests: Are They Truly Reliable?

7/6/2023

 

Lenawee County - Judge Todd M. Morgan and  Laura J. Schaedler

​Drunk driving is a serious offense that endangers the lives of individuals on the road. Lenawee County, located in Michigan, has been grappling with the issue of drunk driving, and the legal battles fought within the 2A District Court shed light on the flaws in field sobriety tests. In this blog post, we will examine the challenges faced by defendants, the deviations from standardized protocols, and the importance of understanding the limitations of these tests.

Field Sobriety Tests: Are They Truly Reliable?

In an ideal world, defendants would not be subjected to field sobriety tests, as these tests are designed to provide evidence of intoxication rather than assist in the defense. However, the reality is that officers often rely on these tests to justify arrests. It is crucial for defendants to be aware of the limitations of these tests and understand their rights.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) manual sanctions only three field sobriety tests. These tests include the walk and turn test, the one-legged stand, and the horizontal gaze nystagmus. However, in Michigan, officers frequently deviate from these sanctioned tests, using improper tests such as reciting the alphabet, counting backward, or estimating time. This departure from established protocols raises questions about the accuracy and fairness of the test results.

Flaws in Field Sobriety Tests

Walk and Turn Test: This test requires defendants to walk heel to toe and turn. However, even sober individuals often struggle to fully comply with its strict requirements. Minor deviations, such as losing balance, starting or ending early, or failing to touch heel to toe on each step, can result in a failed test. Consequently, the reliability of this test as an indicator of intoxication is questionable.

One-Legged Stand: In this test, defendants are instructed to stand on one leg for about 30 seconds. However, this test is challenging for many individuals, especially those with physical conditions or within specific age groups. Swaying, hopping, or using arms for balance can lead to a failed test. It is crucial for defense attorneys to question the assumption that the results of this test are reliable.

Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus: This test relies on observing involuntary eye jerking, which is believed to be caused by alcohol consumption. However, the test's subjectivity and the officers' limited training in conducting eye examinations raise concerns about its accuracy. Various factors other than alcohol consumption can cause eye jerking, making it an unreliable indicator of intoxication.

Preliminary Breath Test (PBT) and its Implications

Alongside field sobriety tests, the Preliminary Breath Test (PBT) plays a significant role in justifying arrests. However, officers often fail to provide clear information about the consequences of refusing this test. It is essential for defendants to understand their rights and the potential outcomes of refusing the PBT.

Refusing the PBT usually results in a civil infraction with minimal consequences. However, officers may mislead defendants by implying that a refusal will lead to severe penalties. Taking the PBT can potentially strengthen the officer's case, as a positive result combined with evidence of driving provides substantial grounds for a legal arrest. The decision to take the test should be made carefully, considering the specific circumstances of each case.

Utilizing PBT Results Strategically

If a PBT is administered, defense attorneys can explore its potential benefits by analyzing the rise or fall in blood alcohol concentration (BAC) levels. When challenging a High BAC/Super Drunk offense in Michigan, where a BAC above 0.17 is required for prosecution, defense attorneys can arguethat a rising BAC level suggests that the defendant's BAC was below the legal limit at the time of driving. By presenting PBT results alongside subsequent Datamaster results, defense attorneys can highlight the fluctuation in BAC levels and cast doubt on the prosecution's ability to prove intoxication beyond a reasonable doubt.

Admissibility of PBT Results

Introducing PBT results into the case requires adhering to specific exceptions outlined in Michigan law. Defense attorneys can utilize the second exception, which allows the defendant to offer the PBT result as evidence of their BAC to counter testimony suggesting a higher BAC at the time of the offense. By skillfully cross-examining the DataMaster operator or persuading the prosecution's witness, defense attorneys may succeed in having the PBT results admitted in court.

Challenges and Fairness

It is important to note that PBT results are not automatically admissible due to their perceived lower reliability compared to the Datamaster. PBT devices often lack regular calibration and may be exposed to extreme temperatures for prolonged periods. However, by understanding the result's context and its potential impact on the case, defense attorneys can strategically use the PBT results to benefit their clients.

Conclusion

The issue of drunk driving and the use of field sobriety tests in Lenawee County's 2A District Court raises concerns about the reliability and fairness of these tests. Defendants must be aware of their rights and the limitations of the tests conducted by law enforcement officers. By questioning deviations from standardized protocols and strategically utilizing PBT results, defense attorneys can challenge arrests and create opportunities for favorable outcomes. It is essential to advocate for a fair and just legal process that upholds the rights of all parties involved.

The main cities and villages in Lenawee County, Michigan which are covered by the 2A District Court, are: Addison, Adrian, Blissfield, Britton, Cement City, Clayton, Clinton, Deerfield, Hudson, Jasper, Manitou Beach, Morenci, Onsted, Palmyra, Riga, Sand Creek, Tecumseh, Tipton, Weston.

Comments are closed.
    Picture
    second offense drunk driving lawyer 2nd offense
    Jonathan Andrew PaulReviewsout of 170 reviews
    Jonathan Andrew PaulClients’ ChoiceAward 2024
    felony drunk driving 3rd offense
    super drunk michigan attorney
    owi lawyer michigan

    Click to Email Me
    Call Me:
    248-924-9458

    dui attorney michigan

    Categories

    All
    911 Tipster
    Accountants
    Acid Reflux Disease
    Alcohol Testing
    Alphabet Test
    Arraignment
    Arrest
    Avoiding Probation
    Avoid Jail
    Bench Trial
    Blood Draw
    Boating Under The Influence
    Body Temperature
    Car Accident
    Career Consequences
    Careless Driving
    CDL
    Challenge Blood Test
    Challenge Jurisdiction
    Challenge Prior Conviction
    Challenge The Arrest
    Challenge The Datamaster
    Chemical Tests
    Child Custody Concerns
    Civil Liability
    Closing Argument
    Cocaine
    Cross Examination
    DAAD Appeal
    Datamaster
    Discovery
    Disorderly Conduct
    Dispatch Logs
    Driver Responsibility Fees
    Driver's License
    Driveway
    Drugged Driving
    Drug Testing
    DUI Causing Death
    DUI Causing Injury
    DUI Dismissal
    DUI Second Offense
    DUI Trial Process
    DUI Warrant
    Educational Consequences
    Feeling Better About Life
    Felony Drunk Driving
    Field Sobriety Tests
    FOIA
    Gas Chromatography
    GERD
    Hair Testing
    Hardship Appeal
    Hardship License
    Heroin
    HGN
    Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus
    Hypoglycemia
    Ignition Interlock
    Implied Consent
    Independent Blood Test
    Infrared Spectroscopy
    Jury Trial
    Losing My Job
    Marijuana
    Medical Conditions
    Medical Marijuana
    Medicaton
    Mental Health Court
    Minor BAC
    Miranda Rights
    Motion To Dismiss
    Mouth Alcohol
    Observation 15 Minutes
    One Legged Stand
    Opening Statement
    Operating Presence Drugs
    Operating While Impaired
    Operating While Intoxicated
    Operation Issues
    Out Of State Convictions
    Out-of-State Convictions
    PBT
    Posting Bond
    Proactive Defense
    Probable Cause To Arrest
    Probation
    Probation Violation
    Prosecutor
    Public Health Code
    Radio Frequency
    Radio Interference
    Reasonable Time Rule
    Reckless Driving
    Refusing Datamaster
    Restitution
    Restricted License
    Right To Counsel
    Rising Blood
    Sentencing
    Sleeping In Car
    Sobriety Court
    Statements
    Subpoena
    Super Drunk
    Super Drunk Arrest
    THC Levels
    Third Offense DUI
    Touching Nose
    Traffic Stop
    Traveling To Canada
    Travel Restrictions
    Urine Testing
    Vehicle Immobilization
    Veteran's Court
    Videos
    Voir Dire Process
    VOP
    Walk And Turn
    Warrants
    Weaving
    Zero Tolerance DUI

Ann Arbor Office Location

Plymouth Office Location

Email Me Now
Picture

Representing DUI Clients in Michigan

Representing clients charged with a DUI in Ann Arbor, Canton, Brighton, Howell, Saline, Adrian, Taylor, Plymouth, Northville, Westland, Ypsilanti, Pittsfield Towsnhip, Warren, Sterling Heights, Farmington, Pontiac, Romulus, Lansing, Novi, South Lyon, Southfield, Birmingham, Bloomfield Hills, Royal Oak, Troy, Rochester, Jackson, East Lansing, Garden City, Livonia, Dearborn, Detroit, St Clair Shores, Hazel Park, Ferndale, Madison Heights, Waterford, Milford, Shelby Township Clarkston, Oak Park, Berkley, Fraser, Sterling Heights, Clinton Township and others throughout Washtenaw, Wayne, Monroe, Jackson, Genesee, Macomb, Ingham, Lenawee, Livingston and Oakland County. ​
  • DUI Playbook
  • Survival Guides
    • Oakland County >
      • Novi
      • Troy Clawson
      • Farmington Hills
      • Bloomfield Hills
      • Rochester Hills Auburn Hills
      • Royal Oak/Berkley
      • Southfield
      • Clarkston
      • Oak Park
      • Waterford
    • Wayne County >
      • Plymouth Canton Northville
      • Livonia
      • Westland
      • Dearborn
      • Woodhaven Brownstown Twp Trenton
      • Romulus Van Burn Twp Belleville
      • Wyandotte Riverview
      • Dearborn Heights
      • Taylor
    • Macomb County >
      • Clinton Township
      • Shelby Township
      • Warren
      • St. Clair Shores
      • Sterling Heights
      • Fraser Roseville
      • Chesterfield New Baltimore
      • Romeo
    • Washtenaw County >
      • Ann Arbor
      • Saline
      • Chelsea
      • Pittsfield Twp
      • Ypsilanti
      • Ypsilanti Twp
    • Lenawee County
    • Genesee County
    • Monroe County
    • Jackson County
    • Livingston County
  • Offenses
    • Operating While Impaired
    • Super Drunk | High BAC
    • Operating Presence Drugs
    • Operating While Intoxicated
    • Minor BAC | Zero Tolerance
    • DUI Expungement
    • OWI Child Endangerment
    • Felony DUI Third Offense
    • DUI Videos
  • Growth Mindset
  • Common Issues
    • Making Substantial Changes
    • Experience Change Model
    • Trial Videos
    • Can the prosecutor prove I was driving?
    • What are my bond conditions?
    • Out of State License
    • Surviving the Implied Consent Law
    • CDL Concerns
    • Field Sobriety / PBT
    • How to beat the blood draw
    • How to beat the Datamaster
  • 5-Star Defense
  • Contact Me
    • Our Team
    • Client Application
  • DUI Expungement
  • Prosecutor Confessions
    • Why I became a Defense Lawyer
    • OWI First Offense
    • OWI Second Offense
    • OWI Third Offense
    • Field Sobriety Tests
    • Implied Consent
    • Hardship Appeal
    • Chemical Tests
    • Sobriety Court
  • Courts
    • Oakland County >
      • More Courts >
        • Oak Park
        • Madison Heights
        • Hazel Park
        • Ferndale
        • Pontiac
        • Waterford
      • Novi 52-1
      • Clarkston 52-2
      • Rochester Hills 52-3
      • Troy 52-4
      • Royal Oak 44th
      • Southfield 46th
      • Farmington Hills
      • Bloomfield 48th
    • Washtenaw County >
      • Ann Arbor
      • Pittsfield Twp 14A1
      • Ypsilanti 14-A
      • Ypsilanti 14-B
      • Chelsea 14A3
      • Saline 14A4
    • Wayne County >
      • More Courts >
        • Redford
        • Lincoln Park
        • 25th District Court Ecorse
        • Wyandotte
        • Southgate
        • 30th District Court Highland
        • Hamtramck
        • Dearborn Heights
        • 32nd District Court Harper Woods
      • Livonia
      • Plymouth 35th
      • Allen Park
      • Romulus
      • Grosse Pointe
      • Woodhaven
      • Dearborn
      • Detroit
      • Garden City
      • Westland
    • Macomb County >
      • Center Line District Court
      • Clinton Township
      • Eastpointe District Court
      • Fraser | Roseville
      • Shelby Township
      • Sterling Heights
      • St Clair Shores
      • New Baltimore | Chesterfield
      • Warren
    • Livingston County
    • Genesee County
    • Jackson County
    • Monroe County
    • Lenawee County
  • Leading with Empathy
  • Reviews